- Get link
- Other Apps
Latest JUSTCAWS Columns
- Get link
- Other Apps
- Wrote this before issue was picked up by Maclean's and others.
- Tue Dec 07 2010
There’s an argument to be made against French immersion
One of the tougher decisions my wife and I have had to make as parents involved the option of enrolling our kids in French immersion. Our school board offers the program at the junior kindergarten level and, therefore, this important decision must be made when a child attains the ripe old age of four.
Many people were shocked that my wife and I, both of us strong believers in education, opted against putting our kids in the program.
The Upper Grand District School Board has done a great job in promoting its French immersion stream, although it seems that the high enrolment in the program has presented challenges in delivering the curriculum.
I’m not surprised at the interest. There’s a wide sense that parents do their child a disservice if they are not enrolled in French immersion.
But some parents fail to consider, or even encounter, the case for why a rational parent might opt out. So, for all those who face this decision, I offer a case against French immersion.
Much of the current research about education suggests the key person in determining success in child’s learning development is the teacher.
Everybody wants the best teachers for their child. In my opinion, the chances of getting the best teachers are not in French immersion. Think about it. When the school board sets out to hire teachers, how many qualified French teachers are available to apply for a job in southwestern Ontario. If I was a principal I would rather select my best teacher candidates from a pool of a 100, than two. This doesn’t mean there aren’t some talented French immersion teachers out there. There are. But the competition for those jobs is less than what it is for ones in the English-language stream. This teacher supply challenge will only grow as French immersion programs increase in popularity.
I’m also concerned about when the French immersion decision must be made. At age four, I have no clue of my kid’s academic abilities.
I have no idea if they will be the next Einstein or will struggle with learning disabilities. If, for whatever reason, they do struggle in French immersion will they be shown the door? If so, what will this do to a child’s self-esteem? Any love of school and learning will surely be diminished if not destroyed. If your kid makes it, great for you. If not, good luck. As a parent, I am not ready to gamble in this way on my kids’ academic future.
For me, education enrichment and development is as much as what goes on outside the classroom as what goes on in it. I want my kids to learn and play with children, from all walks of life, backgrounds, faiths and abilities. I believe there’s more of this diversity outside the French immersion program.
Many argue in the merits of being bilingual, and who could argue? I hope my kids are bilingual adults in whatever language that will serve their interest. But just because a parent passes on French immersion doesn’t mean their child won’t learn French. It’s part of the curriculum. They can take as many French courses as they want in high school — along with a host of other available language courses. I have plenty of family and friends who weren’t in French immersion, but are bilingual.
There is also the matter of choice. Remaining in French immersion means less choice in courses and options than for regular-stream students. I want my kids to be able to follow their interests and explore the widest available variety topics while in school.
I’ve heard some parents say they chose French immersion because they regard it as an elitist program — a sort of private school within the public system. Well, I’m not sure how elitist a program can be when everyone is doing it?
There’s an environmental basis for my decision. Our kids walk to the local community school, while the French immersion kids are bused all over God’s green earth to whatever school can accommodate them. Our board has even displaced some kids from their local school to send them elsewhere, in order to bus in French immsersion students from outside the area. What a waste of money, and a source of excess pollution.
From an environmental perspective, supporting French immersion makes as much sense as living within walking distance of your job then hopping in the car each day and driving around Guelph a few times before finally heading to work.
If someone has chosen the French immersion option, I mean no animosity. We all want what’s best for our kids. I wrote this to add to the French immersion debate. I believe it’s become too one-sided.
Ideally, I would like the province to embed French within the regular curriculum so that any child graduating from an Ontario high school would be bilingual. That would require time, additional resources, and, of course, money.
- There’s an argument to be made against French immersion
One of the tougher decisions my wife and I have had to make as parents involved the option of enrolling our kids in French immersion. Our school board offers the program at the junior kindergarten level and, therefore, this important decision must be made when a child attains the ripe old age of four.
Many people were shocked that my wife and I, both of us strong believers in education, opted against putting our kids in the program.
The Upper Grand District School Board has done a great job in promoting its French immersion stream, although it seems that the high enrolment in the program has presented challenges in delivering the curriculum.
I’m not surprised at the interest. There’s a wide sense that parents do their child a disservice if they are not enrolled in French immersion.
But some parents fail to consider, or even encounter, the case for why a rational parent might opt out. So, for all those who face this decision, I offer a case against French immersion.
Much of the current research about education suggests the key person in determining success in child’s learning development is the teacher.
Everybody wants the best teachers for their child. In my opinion, the chances of getting the best teachers are not in French immersion. Think about it. When the school board sets out to hire teachers, how many qualified French teachers are available to apply for a job in southwestern Ontario. If I was a principal I would rather select my best teacher candidates from a pool of a 100, than two. This doesn’t mean there aren’t some talented French immersion teachers out there. There are. But the competition for those jobs is less than what it is for ones in the English-language stream. This teacher supply challenge will only grow as French immersion programs increase in popularity.
I’m also concerned about when the French immersion decision must be made. At age four, I have no clue of my kid’s academic abilities.
I have no idea if they will be the next Einstein or will struggle with learning disabilities. If, for whatever reason, they do struggle in French immersion will they be shown the door? If so, what will this do to a child’s self-esteem? Any love of school and learning will surely be diminished if not destroyed. If your kid makes it, great for you. If not, good luck. As a parent, I am not ready to gamble in this way on my kids’ academic future.
For me, education enrichment and development is as much as what goes on outside the classroom as what goes on in it. I want my kids to learn and play with children, from all walks of life, backgrounds, faiths and abilities. I believe there’s more of this diversity outside the French immersion program.
Many argue in the merits of being bilingual, and who could argue? I hope my kids are bilingual adults in whatever language that will serve their interest. But just because a parent passes on French immersion doesn’t mean their child won’t learn French. It’s part of the curriculum. They can take as many French courses as they want in high school — along with a host of other available language courses. I have plenty of family and friends who weren’t in French immersion, but are bilingual.
There is also the matter of choice. Remaining in French immersion means less choice in courses and options than for regular-stream students. I want my kids to be able to follow their interests and explore the widest available variety topics while in school.
I’ve heard some parents say they chose French immersion because they regard it as an elitist program — a sort of private school within the public system. Well, I’m not sure how elitist a program can be when everyone is doing it?
There’s an environmental basis for my decision. Our kids walk to the local community school, while the French immersion kids are bused all over God’s green earth to whatever school can accommodate them. Our board has even displaced some kids from their local school to send them elsewhere, in order to bus in French immsersion students from outside the area. What a waste of money, and a source of excess pollution.
From an environmental perspective, supporting French immersion makes as much sense as living within walking distance of your job then hopping in the car each day and driving around Guelph a few times before finally heading to work.
If someone has chosen the French immersion option, I mean no animosity. We all want what’s best for our kids. I wrote this to add to the French immersion debate. I believe it’s become too one-sided.
Ideally, I would like the province to embed French within the regular curriculum so that any child graduating from an Ontario high school would be bilingual. That would require time, additional resources, and, of course, money.
- Get link
- Other Apps
Popular Posts
Teacher Unions - You Need To Calm Down
Been tapping my thumbs quite a bit on twitter lately, as it seems many educators have expressing their concerns of various school re-opening plans. While many of my colleagues have been critical of various governments, my ire has been directed at the teacher unions and their fervent followers. Obviously, my comments have been questioned by teacher union supporters, What they fail to grasp is how a teacher and passionate public education supporter would take issue with their own unions. Perhaps a little background is in order for how my view has developed during my 20 + year career. Being politically minded, I was very interested in the teachers union and its role in public education. Early on I was voted by peers to be my schools collective bargaining rep and later a district federation VP. Here, I received further negotiation training and sat on multiple rounds of negotiations with my corresponding school board. My rose coloured, idealistic glasses were soon broken, by these experie
When The School Bell Rings - We Must Be Ready For All
Been certainly enough speculation from concerned parties about what is going to happen in Ontario Schools this fall. Since I have more than a little skin in the game, I wanted to share my thoughts on the matter. Knowing first hand as an educator and parent the vital role teachers play in the development of young minds I was very satisfied to hear that Sick Kids recommended that school return back to the classroom (with enhanced cleaning and safety measures of course) this fall. I thought this would be met with relief, and it was for some. But for many it seemed to only bring anxiety. I can understand this feeling of unease coming from some parents, but I thought educators would embrace being relevant and essential again. Teachers know the dark side of abuse and neglect that occurs in homes of the vulnerable. For these students, school is their safe space. We also know that e-learning does not work for many students with special needs and those facing tech inequity. So barring a chang
When Will This End? If You Live in The States - Early Next Year.
Update - I am an dual citizen and have discovered I have an American mindset, so I stand by my prediction, as it has come true in the U.S. and many parts of the world, but sadly not in Canada. Limited capacity in our healthcare system, little risk tolerance and the power of the collective over the individual has kept Canada in paralysis. Even with higher case counts in some states than all of Canada, red and blue America has moved on. If you are trying to find a sliver lining to this pandemic a popular one is to appreciate its historical significance. You may have been told or said to others to think of the stories you can tell your grandkids about the pandemic of 2020. Sadly, it will be a sombre tale. But it will be one that I am glad to proclaim will come to an end after one year. Yes, the pandemic will stop as soon as we decide to put an end to the pain and suffering caused. Of course I am not talking about the disease. Sorry, but that's not coming to end just yet.
10 Ideas For The Jays New Ball Park
Kids and I have toured quite a few ball parks prior to the pandemic. Love doing the tours and taking notes of what works and doesn't. Had noted some of my observations for ideas on how to improve the Rogers Centre for baseball. With a new ball park now hopefully on its way soon, I did some revising. Ultimately, I don't believe it will be in its current location as its in too valuable a spot already. Better to leverage cheaper real estate down by the lake and build up around it. The Jays also have few options of where they could play while a new park is being built. So I expect, it will eventually end up by lake, so let's not make it another mistake. But either way here are … My top ten suggestions for the Jays new ball park... Let's end this post appropriately, with a walk off from many fans fav park - PNC.
This Disease Is Fought Standing Shoulder To Shoulder
I am heartened to see many videos and images this morning of Police joining with peaceful protesters in the wake of the murder of George Floyd. While racism in society is pervasive and progress toward true equality moves at a frustratingly slow pace, the relationship citizens have with those sworn with a duty to protect them is at the core of this anger. I am not a police officer and I have no family connection to law enforcement. However, like many of us I know many and some very well. I have heard their stories and have nothing, but respect for the job they do. Many of the officers I know are also black. I have deep admiration for these heroes because I would imagine their sense of duty to their communities comes with an inner battle that must be won before they join that group and don that uniform. So I am careful not to suggest solutions in policing, or offer changes to law enforcement structures that I don’t understand. I am a member of another professional tribe a
JUST Archives
JUST Archives
- June 20211
- March 20211
- January 20212
- November 20201
- October 20203
- August 20201
- July 20202
- June 20206
- May 20204
- April 20201
- March 20201
- February 20201
- January 20201
- December 20191
- November 20191
- July 20192
- May 20191
- April 20192
- March 20192
- January 20191
- December 20181
- November 20181
- December 20101
- May 20101
- August 20081